The Impact of Supplier Concentration on Innovation

Network Rail’s recent report on its £8.8bn supplier expenditure in FY24/25 shows it is concentrated on a small number of Tier 1 suppliers. The same can be said of HS2 where most of its £7bn supply chain expenditure flows through 5 large joint ventures. Many of the suppliers to both organisations are the same.

This high level of supplier concentration, who control around £15bn of expenditure in the market, is probably the most significant whole-system challenge when it comes to scaling up innovation in the UK rail market.

It may well be the main contributor to what is an innovation burning platform in the rail market, where scaling up is a rare exception not the norm.

Past analysis by Interimconsult of funding awards to SMEs and start ups showed that the return on investment was negative. For every £1 spent only 25p of value was created. And this excluded the costs of grant administration and overhead costs including processing applications, award administration, financial reporting, and tracking outcomes.

However, the link between innovation and market-making by government and its arms-length bodies is rarely raised. If it was, the policies and public funding of innovation would be different and the return on investment would be higher.

Network Rail’s report shows:

  • 25% of supplier expenditure was with their Top 5 suppliers
  • 40% of their spend was with the Top 10
  • 54% was with the Top 20

It is reasonable to say that this level of concentration is not necessarily bad. Large suppliers can provide the scale, investment, technical expertise and integration capabilities needed for complex innovation. And many innovations have been brought to market and scaled up via this route.

But a problem arises when supplier concentration becomes sole supplier dependency, reducing the diversity of ideas, technologies and alternative solutions entering the market.

  • They might act as gatekeepers and determine which innovations come to market and get deployed.
  • They have a direct influence on which technologies are considered commercially viable.
  • They may favour their own intellectual property or established partners ahead of other suppliers in the market.
  • They can restrict access to the operational data, infrastructure and testing environments needed prior to full scale deployment.
  • They may not have sufficient incentives or risk appetites to introduce disruptive technologies developed outside their organisation.

Meanwhile, the end-customer can believe it has an open innovation ecosystem when, in practice, there is a relatively narrow route through which innovation can reach the railway.

The Opportunity: Innovation Enablement

To address then challenge of increasing innovation, a greater understanding of the impact of 1st tier supplier concentration is needed. Even if most of the market expenditure is concentrated with a small number of suppliers, systems can still be designed to incentivise scaling up supply chain innovation.

Tier 1’s can be incentivised to take on the important role of ‘innovation enablement’.

This can increase their own competitive advantage by treating supply chain innovation enablement as a strategic capability that helps bring innovations to market faster than their competitors.

Tier 1’s can create opportunities for SMEs and specialist suppliers to develop, test and commercialise new solutions. This includes sharing problem statements, providing access to their own infrastructure and expertise, simplifying B2B procurement and creating pathways for successful innovations to be adopted at scale.

The 3 key takeaways, from a whole systems perspective, are:

  • Government and arms-length-bodies should look at their role as market makers at a whole industry whole-system level, not just by discipline (e.g. signalling, power, civil engineering, etc.).
  • Tier 1 contractors should look at ‘innovation enablement’ in the supply chain as a strategic capability that can deliver a competitive advantage.
  • SMEs and startups should recognise that the “Top 20” Tier 1 suppliers are usually their best route to market. In B2B markets, end-customers rarely buy innovative products and services direct.

None of the above require any significant investment. The industry challenge is to change the long-embedded systemic ways of working that have led to the current situation.

The system needs to change to create the opportunities that increase productivity and make the building and renewal of what is critical national infrastructure, much more affordable.

Sign up to receive regular content about innovation and change

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Sign up to receive regular content in your inbox about innovation and change

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.